Judging Information
Understanding the standards, criteria, and processes behind the Queensland Scale Modelling Championships awards.
Competition enquiry?
Contact the Competition Secretary directly for category, entry, judging, or drop-off questions.
When preparing a model for entry, consider the following criteria that judges look for:
Construction
Preparation of parts: sprue gates removed, mould marks (sink marks, mould release, punch-out marks, etc.) removed
Alignment of parts: do all wheels touch the ground, are wings level, are masts vertical
Seams: all seams filled and sanded smooth
Glue marks cleaned up
Painting
Correct colours based on reference material or kit instructions
Check for overspray or paint runs
Matt or gloss finish applied as appropriate
Decals
Correct placement according to reference material or instructions
Check for visible clear carrier film (silvering)
Finishing
Is the subject weathered appropriately? Reference material is helpful here
Reference
For all categories, but particularly the Enhanced or Modified categories, providing reference material for your subject is critical. As a minimum, it is recommended that kit instructions are provided images of the actual subject are helpful. Consider providing a description of any enhancements or modifications made, along with reference material to show why those changes were made. Examples include alternate marking locations or typical weathering patternsIf modelling a “What If” subject, it is recommended that reference material for the real-world camouflage or marking scheme on which the What If subject is based is provided. Judges will use this reference to assess the What If scheme for accuracy in a similar way to historical subjects
Entry
On the day, ensure your model is presented in its best light
Clean the surface, remove dust, and check for breakage during transport
OUR JUDGING SYSTEM
Many different judging systems are used to determine the outcome of competitions like QMHE, and ours is just one version. It is similar to judging systems used at international competitions such as the US Nationals held annually in America.
We do not use a points-based system.
Three judges are allocated to each competition category and are asked to determine, by consensus, the winning models. Their decisions are ratified by the Chief Judge.
By using a panel of three judges, we aim to ensure that the personal views of one judge are balanced by the views of other experienced judges, and that a fair and balanced decision is reached.
HOW ARE OUR JUDGES SELECTED?
QMHE member clubs are asked to nominate experienced modellers who judge regularly at local competitions or who have judged previously at QMHE. These nominees then form our judging panel.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN YOU DON’T AGREE WITH THE JUDGES’ DECISIONS?
In every competition there are winners and losers. Modellers and visitors will naturally have their own personal favourite models.
Sometimes, the judges’ decisions will not reflect the decisions you might have made if you were judging. We do not expect everyone to agree with every decision, but we trust that our judges will be fair and will use their experience and expertise to make the best possible decisions.
POSSIBLY THE MOST IMPORTANT RULE FOR COMPETITORS
Behave ethically.
Read the competition rules carefully and enter your model in the correct category. While most modellers understand and accept the subjective nature of judging, they will not accept deliberate entry into categories that do not comply with the rules.
While we make every effort to ensure models are entered into the correct category through the scrutineering process, there are a vast number of kits available on the market. Occasionally, it may not be clear whether a modeller has added parts not included in the kit or made modifications not permitted by the category rules.
For this reason, we must rely on the information provided by modellers when they enter their models. If something is overlooked and a model is inadvertently entered into the wrong category, it is likely that experienced modellers attending QMHE will notice, and word spreads quickly.
There is no value in winning or placing in a category if the competition rules were not followed.
Judging Process
"Our judging panel consists of experienced modellers from across various genres. We follow a structured point-based system or a consensus-based 'best of' approach depending on the category requirements."
Need Help?
If you have specific questions about how your model will be judged, please feel free to reach out to our chief judge.
Contact the Team